Thousands of Pokemon Fans Are Missing the Franchise's "Definitive Editions"

Some Pokemon fans are missing the days of “definitive edition” games like Pokemon Yellow and Pokemon Crystal. Pokemon Red and Green were the first games in the franchise, and were released on the original Game Boy. The popularity of the initial games quickly led to Game Freak and Nintendo releasing additional versions with smaller changes, but the core gameplay was left intact.

In the Nintendo Switch era, Game Freak has embraced DLC as a way to offer new Pokemon content while fans wait for the next true generation. Pokemon Sword and Shield began this trend, but fans have seen extra content released in multiple games since. Pokemon Scarlet and Violet received its own expansion in 2023, and Pokemon Legends: Z-A got the Mega Dimension DLC in December 2025.

Pokopia Player Spends Hours Removing the Ocean From Their Game

A dedicated Pokemon Pokopia player manages to remove the ocean from the Nintendo Switch 2 game, after several hours of work.

Where Have the Pokemon “Definitive Editions” Gone?

In a thread on Reddit, many users lamented that the trend of releasing Pokemon definitive editions died with the Switch era. That trend began following Pokemon Red and Green. After those games, Nintendo and Game Freak released Pokemon Blue with some minor changes, before offering Pokemon Yellow: Special Pikachu Edition. For both existing fans and newcomers alike, Pokemon Yellow seemed to be a “definitive edition” for the first generation. Not only did it feature several nods to the Pokemon anime, but it also gave players the opportunity to get Bulbasaur, Charmander, and Squirtle without the need to trade with others. This would kick off a trend for the series that lasted several years, and definitive editions like Pokemon Crystal are considered some of the franchise’s best games.

Game Freak and The Pokemon Company got a little more experimental with mid-gen versions, starting with Pokemon Black and White. That generation skipped a definitive edition in favor of direct sequels, which still took place in the Unova region, but kicked off a new story. Pokemon X and Y seemed to have a third version planned, but it never materialized. Pokemon Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon had big changes and new post-game content, but the same main quest from Sun and Moon, making them the last true definitive editions released for a Pokemon generation.

While some Pokemon fans clearly miss the days of definitive editions, the switch to DLC arguably makes more sense. For one thing, it’s significantly cheaper to buy an expansion versus a whole new game. Releasing content that would have appeared in a definitive edition as DLC also allows players to continue on with their current team, without having to start over from scratch. Had Pokemon Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon‘s Episode RR been released as DLC, existing players could have enjoyed it without having to go through Sun and Moon‘s campaign all over again.

GameRant Quiz

Easy (15s)Medium (10s)Hard (5s)Permadeath (5s)

At this point, it’s a safe bet that the days of Pokemon definitive editions are a thing of the past. Longtime fans might have nostalgia for those releases, but it’s probably a good thing the series has moved on. Luckily, new fans might get a chance to try one of those older definitive editions, as Pokemon Emerald is rumored to be released on Nintendo Switch, alongside Ruby and Sapphire. Nothing has been confirmed at this time, but the positive reception to the re-releases of FireRed and LeafGreen makes it seem very plausible.